>>Atlantic County Medical Society Website
    Home About US
    Membership Calendar
    Member Section
    Physician Resources
    Practice Management
    Patient Resources

    Legislative & Advocacy

    NJ Supreme Court Requires Same Specialty Expert in Medical Liability Lawsuits

    Position Urged by MSNJ

    Today, the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled in Nicholas v. Mynster, a medical liability lawsuit, in which MSNJ and AMA filed an amicus--friends of the court-brief. The high court agreed with our position that a challenging expert must be board certified in the same specialty as a board certified defendant. In doing so, the court adopted a " kind-for-kind" specialty requirement. According to Melinda Martinson, General Counsel of MSNJ, "physicians can now be assured that an expert testifying against them in a medical malpractice case will be qualified on the applicable standard of care and whether there was a deviation from the standard resulting in injury." The court recognized that competency to treat a condition is not the same as the qualifications required by statute to testify to the applicable standard of care. 

    The court interpreted the plain language of the statute that specifies the qualifications of a testifying expert necessary to carry out the clear intent of the Legislature when it enacted the "New Jersey Medical Care Access and Responsibility and Patients First Act" in 2004. MSNJ worked hard to pass the legislation that included the standards for experts testifying in medical malpractice cases. Our efforts were necessary to address sky-rocketing professional liability premiums driven by lawsuits that were without merit. Read the court's opinion.










    Links to helpful resources

    Take Action Now!




    Glenn Insurance, Inc



    Fabietti, Hale, Hammerstedt
    & Powers, PA

    Cape Medical BillingCape Medical Billing

    Copyright © 2019 Cape May County Medical Society

    Copyright © 2019 . All Rights Reserved
    All material, files, logos and trademarks within this site are properties of their respective organizations.
    Terms of Use - Privacy Policy - Contact